Toby's Room opens in the July of 1917, three years after the events of Life Class. Elinor Brooke is still painting, but her brother Toby is shipping out to the front as a Medical Officer, a fact that she cannot bring herself to accept. Toby finds himself on the same Channel crossing as Kit Neville, a close friend--and aspiring suitor--of Elinor's from before the war. Intent on cementing his reputation as an artist, Kit never intended to serve overseas. Conscripted nonetheless, he becomes a stretcher-bearer assigned to assist Toby. It's exhausting, dangerous work, and Kit resents Toby's frequent decisions to risk their own lives in attempting to save the wounded. Confronted daily by their mortality, both men find solace in sexual exploits, but Toby pushes the envelope further by seeking out men, risking a great deal in the process. When Kit sees Toby having sex with another soldier in the ruins of Ypres, he tells the chaplain. Two days later, Toby goes missing (presumed dead) during a bombardment as he runs to the aid of a soldier. News of her missing brother destroys the indifference Elinor has cultivated for so long. She tracks down Kit, who is by now wounded and back in London, but she doesn't believe his version of events. That Kit is cracking up doesn't help; he is soon transferred to a convalescent home where he goes spectacularly mad. Elinor instead turns to her German friend Catherine for comfort, even as Catherine struggles to cope with her own burdens, not least her nationality. Pat Barker is one of Britain's very finest novelists, and in Toby's Room she once again demonstrates her ability to eloquently convey simple, moving truths. A multi-layered exploration of identity, Toby's Room develops the already empathetic and engaging characters of Life Class, exploring at all levels--and across all divides--what it means to be human.
Toby’s Room / Pat Barker
“Elinor Brooke and her brother Toby have a close, if occasionally fractious, relationship. When Toby leaves to fight the Germans in the Great War, Elinor doesn’t know what to do with herself, particularly after she develops a premonition that he will not return home. In this novel, Pat Barker writes about love, loss, and survival, themes that are supported well by Nicola Barber’s able narration. Barber imbues Elinor with a spirit of humanity that makes her easier to empathize with, particularly in her grief. The other characters are a bit less emotionally rounded, but the vocal differentiation is excellent, particularly the—at times, uncomfortable—voicing of the young man who lost his nose in the war.” ~AudioFile
“…[Barker] dives deep into the end of the romantic British Empire and the beginning of modern British existential ambiguity…Booker winner Pat Barker's new novel unravels the secrets of characters introduced in Life Class as they deal with the horrors of the Great War” ~Shelf Awareness (Bruce Jacobs)
“…Barker is peerless at evoking the atmosphere of the trenches and of wartime London, with its gray tea and mystery-meat pies, yet that atmosphere hangs heavily on this novel. At one point Elinor observes in her diary “a frenzy of midges around my bare arms, little frantic things, as if the air had turned to glass and they were trying to get out.” The description serves as an apt metaphor for the novel’s characters, who frequently seem as if they are moving under glass, never quite breaking into life. The story’s inconclusive ending — more a suspension in midair — invites a third installment, to round out a new trilogy; until that point, it’s a tantalizing, unfinished canvas.” ~Washington Post (Joanna Scutts)